McKinsey PEI Questions: What They Are and How to Answer

If you're preparing for a McKinsey interview, understanding the PEI questions is crucial.

Posted August 3, 2023

Table of Contents

If you're applying for a position at McKinsey & Company, you're bound to encounter the Personal Experience Interview (PEI) portion of the recruitment process. This interview assesses your leadership and personal skills through detailed storytelling about your past experiences. Here's what you need to know about McKinsey PEI questions and how to answer them effectively, to land you the job you've been dreaming of.

Why McKinsey PEI Questions are Important

The McKinsey PEI interview questions are crucial because they help the company assess how well you can demonstrate personal attributes that align with McKinsey's core values. Leadership, problem-solving skills, teamwork, and communication are among the essential characteristics the interview team will evaluate during the PEI. This interview helps determine if you're a good fit for the company culture and if you exhibit the skills that the company is looking for in its consultants.

Additionally, the McKinsey PEI interview questions provide an opportunity for you to showcase your unique experiences and accomplishments. By sharing specific examples of how you have demonstrated the desired personal attributes in your past experiences, you can differentiate yourself from other candidates and leave a lasting impression on the interview team. Therefore, it is important to prepare thoroughly for the PEI by reflecting on your past experiences and identifying examples that highlight your leadership, problem-solving, teamwork, and communication skills.

Understanding the Structure of McKinsey PEI Questions

The structure of McKinsey PEI questions consists of asking candidates to answer questions that focus on their past experiences, behaviors, and actions. The goal is to evaluate how you behaved in specific situations and if you demonstrated the desired leadership and problem-solving skills. The interviewer will typically ask open-ended questions such as "Tell me about a time when you had to lead a challenging project." Those questions will require you to tell a detailed story highlighting your experience and demonstrating the core skills requested by the interviewer.

It is important to note that the interviewer is not only interested in the outcome of the situation, but also in the thought process and actions that led to that outcome. Therefore, it is crucial to provide specific examples and details about your actions and decision-making process. Additionally, the interviewer may ask follow-up questions to gain a deeper understanding of your thought process and actions. It is important to be prepared to provide additional information and insights to showcase your skills and experiences.

Free trial!

Access a library of videos, templates, and examples curated by Leland’s top coaches.

undefined's profileundefined's profileundefined's profile

From 109 top coaches

Example Resumes

Example Resumes Image

Example Cases

Example Cases Image

Casing Drills

Casing Drills Image

Mock Interviews

Mock Interviews Image

How to Prepare for McKinsey PEI Questions

The key to acing McKinsey PEI questions is preparation. Before the interview, thoroughly research the company so that you understand its values and culture. Then review the job posting and carefully evaluate the qualities that the company is seeking in its consultants. With this knowledge, prepare a few relevant stories from your past experiences that demonstrate your leadership, communication, teaming, and problem-solving skills. Be sure to practice telling your stories aloud, paying attention to your tone of voice, pauses, and inflection.

In addition to preparing your stories, it is also important to anticipate potential follow-up questions that the interviewer may ask. For example, if you share a story about a time when you demonstrated leadership, the interviewer may ask you to elaborate on how you motivated your team to achieve a specific goal. By anticipating these types of questions, you can prepare more detailed and thoughtful responses.

Another key aspect of preparing for McKinsey PEI questions is to be authentic and genuine in your responses. While it is important to showcase your skills and experiences, it is equally important to be honest about your strengths and weaknesses. The interviewer is looking for candidates who are self-aware and willing to learn and grow, so don't be afraid to share examples of times when you faced challenges or made mistakes. By demonstrating your ability to reflect on your experiences and learn from them, you can show the interviewer that you have the potential to be a successful consultant at McKinsey.

Common McKinsey PEI Questions and Best Answers

Here are some common McKinsey PEI questions you might expect, along with some tips for crafting the best answers:

Tell me about a time when you had to lead a team through adversity. What did you learn?

Here, it's essential to focus on the leadership qualities you displayed and highlight how that experience helped you grow.

Describe a situation where you successfully convinced an individual or a group of people to adopt your idea. How did you do it?

Look for a situation where you had to use your persuasion and communication skills to convince others of your ideas. Illustrate how you approached the challenge and how the outcome benefited everyone.

What are some examples of projects you worked on as part of a team? What role did you play, and what effect did you have?

Choose relevant examples of team projects and your contribution, focusing on your teamwork, communication, and problem-solving skills.

Tips for Answering McKinsey PEI Questions Confidently

To answer McKinsey PEI questions confidently, keep in mind these useful tips:

  • Listen carefully to the question and clarify any doubts before starting to tell your story.
  • Avoid going into too much detail, especially about less relevant information. Stick to the core of your story and make sure it demonstrates the desired competency.
  • Be concise and focused whenever possible. Avoid rambling or tangents that might distract from your answer's relevance.
  • Showcase your personality in your stories, so the interviewers get to know you better beyond your resume and academic achievements.
  • And most importantly, be yourself. Authenticity and honesty are crucial, so don't try to sound like someone you're not.

How to Use the STAR Method for Answering McKinsey PEI Questions

The STAR method is a structured approach to responding to McKinsey PEI questions more effectively. STAR stands for:

  • S - Situation
  • T - Task
  • A - Action
  • R - Result

To use the STAR method, start by outlining the situation that you were in, describe the task that you had to accomplish, explain how you approached the action, and finally describe the result and impact that it had. This method structures your answers, making them more organized, concise, and relevant to the question.

Examples of Successful McKinsey PEI Answers

To give you an idea of what a successful McKinsey PEI answer looks like, here are two examples:

Example One

Situation - I used to run a small charity organization in college that aimed to provide food and essential items for homeless people.

Task - We needed to raise our visibility and increase our reach.

Action - I put together a social media campaign and leveraged our network to get more people involved, including students, alumni, and local businesses.

Result - We doubled our donations within a month. The campaign generated buzz among the community, and we received favorable local news coverage.

Example Two

Situation - I was tasked to lead a critical project for a client in my previous consulting firm.

Task - We had specific and challenging deadlines that we needed to meet.

Action - I led the team effectively by setting clear expectations, motivating everyone to stay focused and energized by creating a positive work environment.

Result - My team delivered the project on time, significantly exceeding the client's expectations. I received positive feedback from both the client and my consulting firm's management.

Top Mistakes to Avoid When Answering McKinsey PEI Questions

Here are some mistakes you'll want to avoid when answering McKinsey PEI interview questions:

  • Being too general - It's crucial to provide specific and detailed examples that demonstrate your skills.
  • Being defensive or negative - Avoid blaming others for problems, making excuses, or speaking negatively about past employers or colleagues.
  • Being overly scripted - While preparation is essential, don't sound like you're reciting a memorized speech.
  • Not showing personality - Remember that the interviewer wants to get to know you, so avoid robotic or overly formal answers.
  • Not answering the actual question - Stay on topic, answer the question asked, and don't veer off on tangents that aren't relevant.

How to Incorporate Your Personal Experiences into McKinsey PEI Answers

Incorporating your personal experiences into McKinsey PEI answers helps give the interviewer insights into who you are as a person and what motivates you. Share stories that are honest and from the heart. Avoid exaggerating or embellishing your stories to sound more impressive. Focus on your personal and leadership qualities rather than strictly on the outcome or success of the story.

Differences between McKinsey's Personal Experience Interview and Competency-Based Interviews

The main difference between McKinsey's Personal Experience Interview and Competency-Based Interviews is that the former focuses more on your personal skills and qualities rather than your technical and functional expertise. In contrast, competency-based interviews assess a candidate's technical knowledge and experience, problem-solving ability, and job-specific competencies.

Preparing for Specific Types of McKinsey PEI Questions

Preparing for specific types of McKinsey PEI questions, such as teamwork, leadership, and communication, requires choosing relevant stories from your past. For example, suppose you're preparing for a teamwork question. In that case, you can choose a story that highlights how you worked effectively with others, overcame challenges working on a team and led to a successful outcome. Preparing for specific types of questions helps you showcase the relevant skills and be more targeted in your answers.

The Role of Culture Fit in McKinsey's Hiring Process

Culture fit plays a significant role in McKinsey's hiring process. The company seeks to create a diverse workforce but also ensures that each consultant reflects the company's values and culture. Being able to demonstrate excellent communication, teamwork, and problem-solving skills is key but showcasing how those skills align with and support the company's culture are equally important.

How to Follow up After a Successful McKinsey PEI Interview

To follow up after a successful McKinsey PEI Interview, send a thank-you email or note to the interviewers expressing your appreciation for their time. Restate how passionate and excited you are about the position, and include any points from the interview that you found particularly interesting. This simple gesture can help you stand out from other candidates and demonstrates your professionalism and interest in the company.

Real-life Insights from Successful Candidates and Recruiters

Successful candidates and recruiters offer insights into McKinsey PEI interviews. Most agree that preparation is key to success, as is being confident and authentic. Candidates recommend practicing telling stories, getting feedback from others, and researching McKinsey's values and culture. Recruiters note that they look for candidates who can effectively communicate their experiences, take ownership of their leadership qualities, and show a passion for the job and the company.

McKinsey PEI interviews can be challenging, but with the right preparation, you can showcase your experiences and demonstrate that you possess the leadership and personal skills the company seeks. By following the tips and guidelines outlined in this article, you'll be well on your way to acing the interview and landing your dream job at McKinsey & Company.

Unlock your full potential with our additional resources tailored specifically for aspiring consultants like you:

Browse hundreds of expert coaches

Leland coaches have helped thousands of people achieve their goals. A dedicated mentor can make all the difference.

Browse Related Articles