Which Management Consulting Firm is Best for Non-Profit?

Discover the top management consulting firms that specialize in non-profit organizations.

Posted May 18, 2023

Table of Contents

In today's rapidly changing world, non-profit organizations face numerous challenges. They strive to stay competitive while addressing donor demands, meeting compliance requirements, and achieving their mission. This is where management consulting firms come into play as they can provide valuable support. But how do you find the right one for your non-profit organization? In this article, we will explore what to consider when choosing a management consulting firm for your non-profit, top firms to consider, evaluation criteria, and much more.

What to Consider When Choosing a Management Consulting Firm for Your Non-Profit

Before you start looking for the right consulting firm, it's essential to understand what your needs are. This includes your organizational goals, the areas you need help with, budget, and timeline. Once you have a clear idea of what you want, it's time to assess potential consulting firms. The following are some of the critical factors that you should consider:

  • Experience: You want a consulting firm that has a proven track record and expertise in your industry or area of focus. Check their previous projects, case studies, and client portfolio to get a sense of their experience and fit for your organization.
  • Team: Who will be working on your project? Who will you be working with directly? Make sure that the consulting firm has a team that is experienced, multidisciplinary, and has the right professional qualifications.
  • Culture: It's essential to find a consulting firm whose culture and values align with those of your organization. This will ensure a smooth working relationship and better outcomes.
  • Communication: The consulting firm should have excellent communication skills, and you should feel comfortable communicating with them.
  • Cost: Consulting firms charge differently depending on their size, expertise, and services. Make sure that you consider your budget while evaluating potential firms.

Aside from the factors mentioned above, there are other things to consider when choosing a management consulting firm for your non-profit. One of these is the consulting firm's approach to problem-solving. Some firms may have a more traditional approach, while others may be more innovative and creative in their problem-solving methods. It's important to choose a firm that aligns with your organization's values and goals.

Another factor to consider is the consulting firm's availability and responsiveness. You want a firm that is readily available to answer your questions and provide updates on the progress of your project. Make sure to ask about their availability and communication channels before hiring them.

Top Management Consulting Firms for Non-Profit Organizations

Several consulting firms specialize in working with non-profit organizations. In no particular order, some of the top ones are:

  • Bridgespan Group
  • BCG Non-Profit
  • FSG
  • The Bridgespan Group
  • Nonprofit Finance Fund
  • Oliver Wyman Social Impact
  • Accenture
  • Mckinsey
  • Deloitte
  • Bain and Company

When choosing a consulting firm for a non-profit organization, it is important to consider the specific needs and goals of the organization. Some firms may specialize in fundraising and development, while others may focus on program evaluation and impact measurement. It is also important to consider the size and budget of the organization, as some consulting firms may be better suited for larger, more established non-profits.

In addition to traditional management consulting services, many firms also offer pro bono or discounted services for non-profit organizations. This can be a great opportunity for smaller organizations with limited resources to access high-quality consulting services that they may not otherwise be able to afford.

Free trial!

Access a library of videos, templates, and examples curated by Leland’s top coaches.

undefined's profileundefined's profileundefined's profile

From 109 top coaches

Example Resumes

Example Resumes Image

Example Cases

Example Cases Image

Casing Drills

Casing Drills Image

Mock Interviews

Mock Interviews Image

How to Evaluate Management Consulting Firms for Non-Profits

Now that you've identified potential consulting firms, it's time to evaluate them further. Here are some factors to consider:

  • Reputation: Check their online reviews, client testimonials, and referrals. Browse their social media handles to gauge their brand reputation.
  • Expertise: Ensure that the consulting firm has experience working with organizations like yours and in the area you need help with.
  • The methodology and approach: Get a sense of how they approach their projects, methodologies used, and the tools they use to measure success.
  • Ability to deliver: Review their project track record and case studies to check if they are consistent in delivering exceptional results.
  • Client involvement: How much do they involve you in the consulting process? Meaningful client involvement is crucial to get desirable outcomes.
  • Flexibility: How flexible are they with timelines, budgets, and scope changes?
  • Leadership team: Gather information on the consulting firm's leadership team and understand their leadership experience.

Another important factor to consider when evaluating management consulting firms for non-profits is their communication skills. It's essential to work with a consulting firm that can communicate effectively with your organization's stakeholders, including board members, staff, and volunteers. Look for a consulting firm that can clearly articulate their ideas, strategies, and recommendations in a way that is easy to understand and implement. Additionally, consider their responsiveness and availability to answer questions and provide updates throughout the consulting engagement.

Differences Between Management Consulting Firms for Non-Profits and For-Profit Businesses

The management consulting needs of the non-profit sector differ significantly from that of for-profit businesses. The objective of non-profit organizations is to achieve a particular social or environmental outcome, making outcomes much harder to quantify. Conversely, for-profit businesses are primarily concerned with financial performance and maximizing shareholder value. Non-profit organizations also face unique challenges such as volunteer management, donor relations, and compliance requirements, requiring specialized consulting expertise.

Another key difference between management consulting for non-profits and for-profit businesses is the funding model. Non-profit organizations rely heavily on donations and grants, which can be unpredictable and subject to fluctuations. This means that non-profit consulting firms must be adept at helping organizations navigate funding challenges and develop sustainable revenue streams. In contrast, for-profit businesses typically have more stable revenue streams and may require consulting services focused on growth and expansion strategies.

Benefits of Hiring a Management Consulting Firm for Your Non-Profit Organization

Non-profit organizations can benefit from enlisting the services of management consulting firms in the following areas:

  • Strategic planning: Non-profit organizations can benefit from developing a comprehensive strategic plan to focus their efforts for maximum impact. Consulting firms can assist with this process.
  • Revenue generation: Consulting firms can help non-profit organizations assess their funding sources and suggest new ways to generate new revenue streams.
  • Organizational efficiency: Consulting firms can help non-profit organizations identify inefficiencies and areas of opportunity to optimize their operations.
  • Compliance: Non-profit organizations need to adhere to various laws and regulations. Consulting firms can assist with compliance requirements, reducing risk to the organization.
  • Board development: Consulting firms can assist non-profits in board development, recruitment, and retention.

Additionally, management consulting firms can provide non-profit organizations with valuable expertise and guidance in areas such as marketing, fundraising, and program evaluation. These firms can help non-profits develop effective marketing strategies to increase awareness and support for their cause. They can also assist with fundraising efforts by providing guidance on donor engagement and stewardship. Finally, consulting firms can help non-profits evaluate the effectiveness of their programs and make data-driven decisions to improve outcomes.

Cost Comparison: Are Management Consulting Firms Worth the Investment for Non-Profits?

Non-profit organizations operate on tight budgets and need to minimize expenses. Management consulting firms don't come cheap, so is it worth investing in them? The answer is that it depends. Consulting firms can help non-profit organizations achieve better results, improve their efficiency, and bring in more revenue. These outcomes can more than justify the expense of hiring a consultant.

However, it's important for non-profits to carefully consider their specific needs and goals before hiring a consulting firm. Some organizations may benefit more from investing in staff training or technology upgrades, while others may require more specialized consulting services. It's also important to research and compare different consulting firms to find one that aligns with the organization's values and mission. Ultimately, the decision to hire a management consulting firm should be based on a thorough analysis of the potential benefits and costs.

Tips for Working Effectively with a Management Consulting Firm as a Non-Profit Organization

Working with a consulting firm can be a significant investment for non-profit organizations. Here are some tips for maximizing the value of the consultant:

  • Communicate your goals: Be clear and precise about your goals for the consulting engagement and what you hope to achieve.
  • Have realistic expectations: Consultants can help expedite progress and achieve outcomes, but they can't work miracles. Have realistic expectations and understand that progress takes time.
  • Be open to feedback: Consultants can identify areas for improvement in your operations and business strategy. Be open to their feedback and be willing to make adjustments.
  • Stay involved: It's important to stay involved in the consulting process. Stay engaged, ask questions, provide feedback, and monitor progress.
  • Integrate recommended changes: Implementing the recommendations made by the consulting firm can be the difference between success and stagnation.
  • Give credit where it's due: Celebrate and recognize the consulting firm's contributions to your organization's success.

Another important tip for working effectively with a management consulting firm as a non-profit organization is to establish a clear and open line of communication. This means setting up regular check-ins and progress updates, as well as being transparent about any challenges or concerns that arise during the consulting engagement. By maintaining a strong and collaborative relationship with your consultant, you can ensure that you are getting the most out of your investment and achieving your desired outcomes.

Common Challenges When Working with a Management Consulting Firm as a Non-Profit and How to Overcome Them

Working with a consulting firm is not without its challenges. Some of the most common challenges that non-profit organizations face when working with management consultants include:

  • Resistance to change: Stakeholders who aren't committed to change can be a significant obstacle to any consulting project. Identifying and addressing resistance to change is essential to ensure successful outcomes.
  • Managing expectations: Setting realistic expectations, communicating regularly, and anticipating problems before they arise are all ways to manage expectations successfully.
  • Budget constraints: Budget constraints can limit the scope of consulting projects. Identifying the most critical business challenges and prioritizing accordingly can help overcome budget constraints.
  • Scope creep: Scope creep is when the consulting project's objectives and goals keep expanding. Setting clear boundaries and expectations at the outset can prevent scope creep.


In conclusion, finding the right management consulting firm can be a game-changer for non-profit organizations. Start by identifying your needs and evaluating potential consulting firms based on their expertise, reputation, team, culture, communication, and cost. Expect measurable outcomes, stay engaged in the process, and prepare for some challenges. If you keep these tips in mind, you're well on your way to finding the right consulting firm and maximizing their value to your organization.

Browse hundreds of expert coaches

Leland coaches have helped thousands of people achieve their goals. A dedicated mentor can make all the difference.

Browse Related Articles