Physician Assistant Vs. MD: Which One Is Right for You?

Are you considering a career in healthcare but unsure whether to become a physician assistant or a medical doctor? This article explores the differences between the two professions, including education requirements, job responsibilities, and potential salaries, to help you make an informed decision about which path is right for you..

Posted May 19, 2023

Table of Contents

Choosing a career in healthcare can be a daunting task, especially with the many options available. Two career paths that often get confused with each other are physician assistants (PAs) and medical doctors (MDs). While both are crucial in ensuring the healthcare system runs smoothly, there are significant differences between the two professions that prospective students need to consider before choosing a career path. In this article, we will break down the differences between these two healthcare professionals and help you decide which one might be right for you.

Understanding the Differences Between Physician Assistants and Medical Doctors

Physician Assistants and Medical Doctors both play critical roles in the healthcare system and work together to provide the best possible care for patients. However, they have different roles and responsibilities that distinguish them from one another. A Physician Assistant works under the supervision and guidance of a Medical Doctor to diagnose and treat illnesses. They can take medical histories, conduct physical exams and order diagnostic tests or imaging as well as assist in procedures. PAs can also prescribe medication in accordance with state laws. On the other hand, Medical Doctors can perform surgeries, diagnose and treat conditions, prescribe medication, among other things but do not work under the supervision of others. While there are similarities in their medical responsibilities, significant variations exist in their scopes of practice and scope of authority.

It is important to note that Physician Assistants and Medical Doctors often work together in a collaborative team-based approach to provide the best possible care for patients. This approach allows for a more comprehensive and coordinated approach to patient care, with each healthcare professional bringing their unique skills and expertise to the table. Additionally, both PAs and MDs are required to complete rigorous education and training programs, and must maintain their knowledge and skills through ongoing continuing education and professional development.

What is a Physician Assistant?

A Physician Assistant is a healthcare provider who operates under the supervision of a Medical Doctor. The PA profession originated as a way to provide additional medical support services and was designed to meet the demand for healthcare providers in underserved communities. PAs are trained to conduct physical exams, diagnose illnesses, and perform procedures under the supervision and guidance of a Medical Doctor. They can also order diagnostic testing and write prescriptions depending on the laws of the state they practice in. Most PAs practice in physician offices, surgery centers and hospitals, with some specializing in various fields such as emergency medicine, pediatric, obstetrics among others.

What is a Medical Doctor?

A Medical Doctor is a healthcare professional licensed to practice medicine, and their role is to diagnose and treat illnesses, perform surgeries and provide medical care to patients. Doctors have diverse specializations, and they work in different settings, including hospitals and clinics. The training for becoming a medical doctor is extensive, with a minimum of 11 years of post-secondary education required. In addition, medical doctors are required to pass rigorous licensing exams and complete several years of residency training in their respective fields. MDs work independently and have more authority in making medical decisions than physician assistants.

Education and Training Requirements for Physician Assistants

To become a Physician Assistant, one must complete a two-year master's program that is accredited by the Accreditation Review Commission on Education for the Physician Assistant. Other requirements include having a bachelor's degree, health care experience, and passing the Physician Assistant National Certifying Exam (PANCE). Once the PA program and exam requirements are complete, licensees are authorized to work alongside physicians to diagnose and treat illnesses.

Education and Training Requirements for Medical Doctors

Medical Doctors, on the other hand, have an extensive education path as it takes 11 years of post-secondary education to become an MD. The path starts with a four-year undergraduate degree, followed by four years of medical school, and a minimum of three years of residency training, which could last up to five years in some specializations. After the Residency, MDs are required to pass a licensing exam by the National Board of Medical Examiners before obtaining their license to practice medicine.

Salary Comparison: Physician Assistants vs. MDs

The pay scale between the two professions is quite different. As of 2021, the median annual salary for a Physician Assistant is around $112,260, while the median annual salary for a Medical Doctor is approximately $206,500, which is almost double the salary of a Physician Assistant. However, salaries vary depending on the state they practice, experience level, and specialization.

Job Responsibilities of Physician Assistants vs. MDs

Physician Assistants are expected to have clinical duties such as diagnosing and treating illnesses, writing prescriptions, and keeping records of patient care, among other responsibilities. However, they need to consult with a Medical Doctor concerning complex or severe cases and to help with any procedures that require a physician. In contrast, Medical Doctors have significant authority over the healthcare team and have full responsibility for patient care, including complex diagnoses and treatments. They can also perform surgeries depending on their specialty.

Pros and Cons of Being a Physician Assistant vs. MD

Choosing a career is not easy, and each option has its advantages and disadvantages. Physician Assistant's primary advantage is flexibility. The profession offers flexibility in terms of specialization, location of practice, and work hours. It also has a lower education cost than becoming a Medical Doctor. However, the benefits for becoming an MD are better pay, autonomy in medical decisions and more variety in terms of specialties to choose from. The main drawbacks of becoming a Medical Doctor are the extensive education requirements and the significant student debt. Higher autonomy also comes with extra paperwork and administrative duties.

Job Outlook for Physician Assistants vs. MDs

The job outlook for both professions is expected to grow significantly. According to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, employment of Physician Assistants is projected to grow 31% from 2019 to 2029, higher than the 16% projected growth rate for all occupations. The growth is due to an aging population and the increasing demand for healthcare services globally. The demand for Medical Didctors is also projected to grow at K to 7%. However, MDs will face stiffer competition due to the high pay associated with the career path, and more candidates are expected to compete for available positions.

How to Decide Which Career Path to Choose: Factors to Consider

When deciding between these two professions, you need to consider your educational background, career interests, preferred work environment, and job duties. You should also consider the level of responsibility, the actual pay scale, and flexibility. Other factors may include personal values, lifestyle preferences, passion, and work-life balance.

Can You Switch from Being a Physician Assistant to an MD?

It's possible to move from being a Physician Assistant to an MD, although it is a time-consuming and rigorous process. The primary route to becoming an MD involves completing a pre-medical degree followed by four years of medical school and then completing a residency program. However, some PA's have a degree in medicine before pivoting to becoming a Physician Assistant. PAs interested in transitioning to an MD must meet all medical school admission requirements and complete all program requirements.

How to Become a Successful Physician Assistant or MD

To become a successful Physician Assistant or MD, one must have a positive attitude, be accountable, dedicated, empathetic, and detail-oriented. They must be able to work under pressure, a team player (for PAs) and have excellent communication skills. A focus on continuous professional development and staying up to date with best practices is also critical to maintaining clinical competency.

The Role of Physician Assistants in Modern Healthcare

Physician Assistants play an essential role in modern healthcare, mainly as a supplement for overburdened medical systems and physicians. They provide quality and cost-effective care to patients while reducing the workload for physicians. PAs also enjoy a high level of patient satisfaction due to their personalized approach and availability for conversation.

The Role of Medical Doctors in Modern Healthcare

Medical Doctors hold an indispensable place in modern healthcare. They are responsible for diagnosing, treating, and managing complex medical conditions and diseases. MD's also help promote public health through health education and advocacy, and can perform lifesaving procedures improving patient outcomes. They work tirelessly to become experts in various fields of medicine to meet unique patient needs.

Top Schools for Physician Assistant Programs

The top schools for Physician Assistant Programs in the US are Duke University, Emory University, University of Iowa, Baylor College of Medicine, and George Washington University. Other great options include Yale University School of Medicine, Rutgers University, University of Wisconsin-Madison, and University of Utah.

Top Schools for Medical Doctor Programs

The top schools for Medical Doctor Programs are Harvard University, Stanford University, John Hopkins University, University of California-Los Angeles, and Mayo Clinic School of Medicine. Other notable options are the University of Pennsylvania, University of Michigan-Ann Arbor, Duke University, Yale University School of Medicine, among others.

In conclusion, deciding between becoming a Physician Assistant and a Medical Doctor can be an overwhelming task. While both professions are critical in improving the healthcare system, several differences exist that require careful consideration before choosing a path. The right path will depend on several factors unique to you, such as education, experience, interest, and personality. Ensure you have all the necessary information before deciding, and choose the path that aligns with your career aspirations and values.

Browse hundreds of expert coaches

Leland coaches have helped thousands of people achieve their goals. A dedicated mentor can make all the difference.

Browse Related Articles